top of page

Unveiling the Quiet Destruction of Our Planet

Exploring the Hidden Costs of Environmental Change Through the Lens of Poetry and Reflection

​

​

Written by

Sune' Erasmus

u22550497

2024/10/02

Environmental Humanities and Slow Violence: A Reflection on Ecosystems and Biodiversity

From the merging of ideas grounded in philosophy, literature, history, and the arts, we recognise that Environmental Humanities is inherently cross-functional (Rissman & Barrow, 2019). This term primarily defines the complex relationship between Homo sapiens and the natural environment (Kraft, 2021). By integrating a humanistic approach with scientific knowledge, this field strives to address the major environmental challenges we face in the twenty-first century (Duara, 2017). The humanities serve as a critical bridge, addressing the human dimensions of environmental and climate change issues (Kraft, 2021).

​

The contributions of Environmental Humanities lie in providing insights into our daily interactions with the environment, focusing on the philosophical, historical, and cultural dimensions of environmental questions. This multifaceted approach encourages empathetic reflections on how our ideologies, narratives, and actions shape our relationship with nature (Rissman & Barrow, 2019). Such perspectives are vital (Duara, 2017) as they connect to the solutions we seek for environmental problems rooted in the twentieth century.

​

The term "Anthropocene" describes the current geological period, characterised by human-induced changes to Earth's ecosystems and geology (Steffen, 2011). This concept, like the suspicion of global warming, challenges traditional notions of humanity’s place in nature (Holm, 2015). The Anthropocene urges immediate action towards sustainability and calls for reevaluating governance frameworks and economic models. Duara (2017) asserts that humanistic approaches are crucial for effectively addressing these challenges.

​

Eco-criticism examines the representation of nature in literature and other cultural productions (Holm, 2015). It reveals how cultural depictions influence our attitudes and actions towards the environment. Environmental justice critiques the unequal distribution of environmental costs and benefits across social groups, as emphasised by O’Gorman (2019, p.448). This theory advocates for fair solutions to ensure that vulnerable populations are not disproportionately burdened by environmental issues.

​

The concept of non-human agency, discussed by Holm (2015, p.989), challenges anthropocentric views, emphasising the roles of non-human actors—such as plants, animals, and ecosystems—in shaping environmental outcomes. This shift encourages us to rethink our perceptions of agency within the natural world.

​

The Environmental Humanities engages with various investigative approaches, including historical analysis, which seeks to understand how past human interactions with the environment have led to current ecological challenges. This methodology allows researchers to trace present-day environmental issues back to historical human practices and decisions. Additionally, a philosophical exploration of the ethical dimensions of human-environment interactions invites moral reflection on our responsibilities towards nature.

​

Literary and cultural studies examining how environmental questions are depicted in art, literature, and media are also essential in shaping public perceptions of environmental issues. These cultural analyses illustrate how the arts and media can reflect societal attitudes towards nature, influencing public opinion and policy.

​

Recent scholarship highlights how the humanities intersect with complex, interconnected environmental problems. As noted by Holm et al. (2015, p. 981-985), humanities research can provide significant insights into "wicked problems," which are characterised by interrelated causes and effects that often lead to unforeseen consequences. Kraft (2021) stresses the need for an interdisciplinary approach to environmental research that accommodates diverse perspectives and future scenarios, ultimately facilitating a deeper understanding of environmental complexities and new pathways towards sustainability.

​

Rissman & Barrow (2019) underscore the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration in environmental research among graduate students. Those engaged in interdisciplinary work reported feeling more supported by their intellectual communities compared to those who viewed conservation as a solitary endeavour. However, challenges arise when students collaborate with non-academic partners, indicating a need for improved training in collaborative skills within environmental studies.

​

The concept of the Anthropocene, as elaborated by Duara (2017), extends beyond scientific discourse to challenge conventional wisdom and economic frameworks. It raises essential questions regarding political governance, economic models, public opinion, and corporate responses. Arts-based methodologies, such as those employed by Rafiki Theatre for WASH (Maddan & Smith, 2020, p.1-6) in refugee camps, demonstrate how creative approaches can engage communities in solving complex problems.

​

Experiential learning initiatives, such as the On-Water Research Intensive at the University of Pennsylvania and reflective journaling at Macquarie University, exemplify diverse pedagogies within the Environmental Humanities that address complex environmental issues (O'Gorman et al., 2019, p.456). These examples illustrate the variability in teaching methodologies across institutions, reinforcing the idea that there is no singular way to confront environmental challenges.

​

One day the day will come when the day won’t come; although it’s not today, that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t care. The term "Slow Violence," as articulated by Rob Nixon, describes violence that unfolds over time and is not immediately visible (Nixon, 2011:3). The disappearance of ecosystems and the loss of biodiversity exemplify slow violence, leaving deep scars on both nature and human well-being.

​

Disappearing Ecosystems as Slow Violence

Slow violence, as described by Nixon, emphasises the gradual destruction of ecosystems that occurs not through sudden dramatic events but rather through slow, insidious processes. This creeping destruction, observable in rainforests and coral reefs, reveals itself over the long term, with impacts accumulating over time. Rachel Carson’s observations of invisible chemical contamination highlight how chronic harm to ecosystems and human health can persist unnoticed (Carson, 1962: 9,12). The gradual destruction aligns with Nixon’s concept of slow violence due to the protracted diffusion of its effects.

​

Richard Fisher elaborates that slow violence often remains hidden in plain sight, occurring so gradually that individuals may fail to recognise its presence. Despite witnessing the severe, lasting consequences of slow violence—such as ecosystem collapse and biodiversity loss—awareness often lags behind the reality of these issues (Fisher, 2021).

​

Elizabeth Kolbert's analysis of the current extinction crisis sheds light on how habitat destruction, climate change, and human activities contribute to slow violence through the gradual loss of biodiversity. As Kolbert illustrates, environmental transformation unfolds in phases, rendering the situation increasingly invisible and unmanageable over time (Kolbert, 2014).

​

Biodiversity Damage in a Gradual Manner

While background extinction refers to the gradual and natural disappearance of species, mass extinction involves the simultaneous decline of numerous species (Kolbert, 2014: 8, 15-16). Nixon's notion of slow violence resonates deeply with the biodiversity crisis we face today. Human actions—such as deforestation and pollution—accelerate extinction rates, reminiscent of past extinction events in Earth's history. Yet today’s unravelling occurs at a more insidious pace, reducing immediate visibility but proving equally destructive over time.

​

Fisher highlights that slow violence often emanates from systems that appear benign or beneficial, yet result in substantial environmental damage over time. This gradual weakening masks accountability among those responsible, allowing biodiversity loss and environmental devastation to persist without public scrutiny (Fisher, 2021). Whitehouse identifies habitat fragmentation and climate change as key contributors to gradual biodiversity loss, reinforcing Nixon's notion of slow violence. Unlike dramatic environmental catastrophes, these subtle processes inflict long-term devastation on ecosystems and species. Fisher further notes that vulnerable communities bear the brunt of these changes, often lacking the resources to address the damage (Fisher, 2021).

​

Difficulty in Representation and Mobilisation

Representing slow violence proves challenging. Nixon asserts that media coverage tends to focus on dramatic, immediate acts, rendering slow violence less visible and harder to recognise (Nixon, 2011:3). Fisher expands on this, emphasising that slow violence is often too incremental to generate headlines or provoke outrage (Fisher, 2021). To confront this representational challenge, Carson and Kolbert advocate for new storytelling approaches that effectively capture the urgency of addressing slow, long-term violence (Carson, 1962; Kolbert, 2014).

​

In summary, lost ecosystems and diminished biodiversity are indicators of the pervasive nature of slow violence, whose effects unfold through subtle, often invisible processes. The concepts presented elaborate on Nixon's framework of environmental destruction, as narrated by Carson, Kolbert, and Whitehouse, and further explored by Fisher. Acknowledging the existence of slow violence is the first step toward addressing it, enabling us to devise strategies that secure our environment for future generations. The day may not come immediately, but inevitably it approaches when the day won’t come at all.

Introduction to the Photo-Essays in the Environmental Humanities:

The photo essays were convenient ways in which complicated ideas related to environmental challenges could be brought into vision. They represent peculiar approaches to applied photography both as far as intellectual insights and therefore philosophical concerns and in making abstract thought more concrete and real.  According to Pauwels (2012, p.1-2), a photo essay can bridge the gap between public and scientific research by presenting an engaging, easily accessible, and inviting way of viewing environmental issues.

Figure 1: Cotton Pads for Makeup Removal (Taken by Suné Erasmus)
A Closer Look: The Impact of Cotton Pads

​

Ecocriticism:

Most households rely on cotton pads for various purposes, including makeup removal and wound cleaning. However, the environmental degradation caused by their production is substantial. The systematic cultivation of cotton requires massive amounts of water—approximately 20,000 litres for just one kilogram—and relies heavily on toxic pesticides and fertilizers. These chemicals often seep into surrounding ecosystems, leading to devastating consequences for biodiversity, such as the decline of essential species and disruptions in food chains (Euronews, 2018). Additionally, the sheer volume of cotton pads discarded annually is staggering; tens of millions find their way to landfills, primarily due to consumer ignorance regarding their environmental impact. These products can take years to decompose, further exacerbating pollution and waste issues (Euronews, 2018).

​

Eco-Action:

Transitioning to reusable cotton pads or opting for biodegradable alternatives can significantly alleviate waste and mitigate the environmental impact associated with conventional cotton farming practices. Such shifts not only reduce landfill contributions but also foster a more sustainable lifestyle. Small, everyday actions—like choosing eco-friendly products—can collectively yield meaningful changes for our planet. By making informed choices, consumers can actively participate in protecting ecosystems and promoting environmental health for future generations.

3,365 children under the age of five died in South Africa in 2021 as a result of air pollution.
South Africa ranks eighth in the world for the number of infants who pass away before turning five due to reasons related to ambient particulate matter, of which burning fossil fuels is a major contributor.

UNICEF South Africa

2car.jpg

Fig 2: Urban Pollution of an Exhaust Pipe (Taken by Suné Erasmus)
Exhausting Our Future: A Closer Look

Eco-Critique

Fossil fuel-powered vehicles are a major contributor to air pollution, releasing over half of the nitrogen oxides that significantly impact the environment and public health, particularly in urban areas (Union of Concerned Scientists, 2008). The close-up of this tailpipe serves as a stark visual reminder of the consequences of our reliance on fossil fuels, prompting a critical reflection on individual contributions to the larger problem of air pollution. These emissions not only exacerbate global warming but also lead to a range of health issues, including respiratory problems and cardiovascular diseases. By highlighting the impact of a seemingly innocuous component of daily life, this image challenges us to consider our role in perpetuating these environmental and health crises.

​

Eco-Action

Addressing these pressing issues requires comprehensive action, including stricter regulations on vehicle emissions and a substantial investment in clean energy technologies. Transitioning to alternative transportation methods such as electric vehicles, public transit, and biking can significantly reduce our dependence on fossil fuels. Shifting towards sustainable energy sources will not only enhance air quality but also promote public health. By collectively embracing these eco-friendly alternatives, we can foster a cleaner, healthier environment for future generations.

Carbon dioxide (COâ‚‚) emissions from fossil fuel and industrial purposes in South Africa from 1970 to 2022
(in million metric tons)

exhaust.jpg

Statista

tree.jpg

Fig. 3: Drought Affected Landscape (Taken by Suné Erasmus)
The Parched Earth: A Reflection on Drought

Eco-Critique:

This poignant photo illustrates the profound impact of climate change and drought on Southern Africa's ecosystems, affecting over 61 million people due to extreme weather conditions (UN OCHA, 2024). The arid landscape, characterised by desiccated trees and parched grass, serves as a stark reminder of the threats posed by drought to biodiversity and agriculture. As ecosystems become increasingly fragile, the consequences ripple through local communities that depend on agriculture for their livelihoods. These changes not only disrupt food production but also jeopardise the flora and fauna that sustain the region's natural balance.

​

Eco-Action:

Addressing these pressing challenges requires immediate and concerted efforts. Implementing practical and effective water conservation strategies can help communities manage their scarce resources more sustainably. Additionally, adopting sustainable agricultural practices, such as crop rotation and agroforestry, can bolster resilience against climate variability. Furthermore, global investment is crucial to develop technologies and infrastructure that mitigate the effects of climate change. By taking these collective steps, we can work towards restoring balance and resilience in the environment, ultimately safeguarding the future of Southern Africa's ecosystems and the people who rely on them. Every effort counts in the fight against climate change and its far-reaching consequences.

Early in 2024, a protracted dry period in southern Africa burned crops and jeopardised millions of people's access to food.

NASA Earth Observatory

drought.jpg
drought 2.jpg

The map displays the soil moisture conditions in southern Africa for March 2024 at the root zone, which is a measure of the amount of water available for crops. Indices of orange and red indicate low soil moisture content.

NASA Earth Observatory

lime.jpg

Fig. 4: Land Subsidence (Taken by Suné Erasmus)
The Hidden Costs of Lime Mining: A Slow Descent

The image captures the gradual process of land subsidence associated with lime mining, where excessive extraction of groundwater, combined with natural geological processes, leads to slow but significant changes in the landscape. This phenomenon exemplifies what Rob Nixon refers to as "slow violence," a form of harm that occurs incrementally rather than through dramatic events. Over time, the subsiding ground can inflict considerable damage on infrastructure, including buildings and roads, as well as disrupt local ecosystems. Nixon emphasises that this attritional harm is often only recognised when it reaches its most extreme forms.

​

The United States Geological Survey highlights the high repair costs and increased flooding risks associated with subsidence, particularly in regions like Colorado. Here, issues such as collapsing soils, sinkholes, and complications arising from old, abandoned mines illustrate the long-term impacts of mining practices on the environment.

​

As lime mining continues, the gradual deterioration of land stability poses a serious threat to both human structures and the surrounding natural world. This image serves as a poignant reminder of the urgent need for sustainable management strategies to mitigate the effects of slow violence and protect our landscapes and communities for future generations.

earth.jpg

Fig. 5: Desertification (Taken by Suné Erasmus)
Turning Earth to Dust: The Impact of Desertification

Desertification serves as a stark example of slow violence, where once-fertile and vibrant land gradually transforms into dry and lifeless terrain. This insidious process unfolds over time, driven by a combination of continuous drought, deforestation, and unsustainable farming practices. As the soil loses its fertility, it becomes incapable of sustaining wildlife and agricultural production, leading to a dramatic decline in biodiversity. The reduction in viable crops and the inability to generate income from the land translates into rising poverty for communities that depend on agriculture for their livelihoods.

​

According to Iberdrola, more than 2 billion people worldwide are affected by the consequences of desertification, making it a pressing environmental and socioeconomic issue. The transformation of fertile land into an arid desert not only disrupts local ecosystems but also exacerbates poverty and food insecurity among millions. This situation underscores the urgent need for effective land management and restoration strategies to combat desertification. By actively caring for and restoring the land, we can mitigate these detrimental impacts and work towards safeguarding both the environment and the lives of those who rely on it. Addressing desertification is essential for creating a sustainable future for both people and the planet (Iberdrola, n.d.).

deg 2.jpg
deg.jpg

DEPARTMENT OF FORESTRY, FISHERIES AND THE ENVIRONMENT

Thank you!

Sources Consulted:

Duara, P., 2017. Environmental Humanities and Sustainable Modernity in Asia (and Beyond). Available at: [https://items.ssrc.org/just-environments/environmental-humanities-and-sustainable-modernity-in-asia-and-beyond/] [Accessed 30 August 2024].

​

Holm, P. et al. 2015. Humanities for the Environment—A Manifesto for Research and Action. Humanities 4:977-992. 

​

Kraft, M.E., 2021. Environmental Policy and Politics. 8th ed. New York: Routledge. Available at: https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/mono/10.4324/9781003106265/environmental-policy-politics-michael-kraft [Accessed 1 September 2024].

​

Maddan, H and Smith, B. 2020. Water, sanitation and hygiene in refugee camps in Uganda: photo essay, Research in Drama Education: The Journal of Applied Theatre and Performance. 

​

O’Gorman, E. et al. 2019. Teaching the Environmental Humanities: International Perspectives and Practices. Environmental Humanities 11(2):427-460. 

​

Rissman, A.R. and Barrow, L., 2019. Characteristics of Collaborative, Interdisciplinary, and Engaged Research Among Graduate Students in Environmental Conservation. Available at: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13412-019-00553-0 [Accessed 30 August 2024].

​

Steffen W. et al 2011. The Anthropocene: conceptual and historical Perspectives. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 369: 842–867. .

​

Pauwels, L. 2012. Conceptualising the 'Visual Essay' as a way of generating and imparting sociological insight: issues, formats and realisations. Sociological Research Online 17(1):[sp]. 

​

Euronews (2018). The dark side of cotton pads. Euronews. Published 19 November. Available at: https://www.euronews.com/green/2018/11/19/the-dark-side-of-cotton-pads (Accessed: 2 September 2024).

 

Union of Concerned Scientists (2008). Cars, trucks, and buses and air pollution. Union of Concerned Scientists. Published 23 July. Available at: https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/cars-trucks-buses-and-air-pollution (Accessed: 2 September 2024).

 

UN OCHA (2024). Southern Africa in the grip of severe drought. UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. Published 20 May. Available at: https://www.unocha.org/publications/report/madagascar/southern-africa-grip-severe-drought (Accessed: 2 September 2024).

​

Fisher, R., 2021. The invisible impact of slow violence. BBC Future. Available at: https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20210127-the-invisible-impact-of-slow-violence [Accessed 12 September 2024].

​

Carson, R. 1962. Silent Spring. London: Penguin.

​

Kolbert, E. 2014. The Sixth Extinction: An Unnatural History. New York: Henry Holt. 

​

Nixon, R. 2011. Slow violence and the environmentalism of the poor. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.   

​

Whitehouse, A. 2015. Listening to birds in the Anthropocene: the anxious semiotics of sound in a human-dominated world. Environmental Humanities 6:53-71. 

​

Colorado Geological Survey, n.d. Ground Subsidence. Colorado Geological Survey. Available at: https://coloradogeologicalsurvey.org/hazards/ground-subsidence/ [Accessed 13 September 2024].

​

World Wildlife Fund, n.d. Deforestation and forest degradation. Available at: https://www.worldwildlife.org/threats/deforestation-and-forest-degradation [Accessed 13 September 2024].

​

Iberdrola, n.d. Desertification. Available at: https://www.iberdrola.com/sustainability/desertification [Accessed 13 September 2024].

​

NASA Earth Observatory (2023) Severe drought in southern Africa. Available at: https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/152711/severe-drought-in-southern-africa (Accessed: 2 October 2024).

​

UNICEF, 2023. Air pollution accounted for some 3,365 deaths of children under five years across South Africa. Available at: https://www.unicef.org/southafrica/press-releases/air-pollution-accounted-some-3365-deaths-children-under-five-years-across-south [Accessed 2 October 2024].

​

Statista, 2023. COâ‚‚ emissions from fossil fuel and industrial purposes in South Africa from 1990 to 2021 (in million metric tons). Available at: https://www.statista.com/statistics/486073/co2-emissions-south-africa-fossil-fuel-and-industrial-purposes/ [Accessed 2 October 2024].

​

Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE). (n.d.). National Action Programme on Desertification, Land Degradation and Drought Effects. Available at: https://www.dffe.gov.za/sites/default/files/docs/nap_desertification_land_degradation_droughteffects.pdf [Accessed: 02 October 2024].

bottom of page